About Us


Our Family Business

The Butcher Shoppe originated in 1983 with our father, Mike Baumgart and a partner. In 1999, the partners retired, dad took over the business and pushed and created who we are now. We have carried on the family business and have enjoyed working together as a family for decades. As young boys, dad had us working at the shop teaching us the old fashioned way to cut and produce meat products. He also stressed the importance of quality food and customer service. In 2004, the Smokehouse was begun adding cooked products to the choices. As of July 2014 the sons of Mike Baumgart, Michael and Chris, have taken over the family business and strive to continue the legacy. We are introducing products that fit with today's life style while keeping the old fashioned ways of the Butcher Shoppe. We continue dad's work while developing and bringing in a variety of products that will keep customers coming back for more.

Contact Us

(812) 423-2465
2130 Stringtown Rd.
Evansville, IN 47711


Tue-Fri: 9AM-6PM
Saturday: 8AM-5PM
Sun-Mon: Closed

Say Hello

For any order or if you have any questions about cooking please feel free to reach out and say hello. We love connecting with people in our community!

We accept: Visa, MasterCard, Discover, EBT, Cash, No Personal Checks
- Gift Cards are Available -


Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe

Share by: